UTAS National Family Safety Research Initiative · Final report · July 2026

Crisis Without Response.

How systems fail families living with severe attachment-related disorders. Three surveys. 320 families. One consistent, documented story.

Family respondents
320
Survey submissions
648
Survey instruments
3
U.S. states represented
46/50

Key finding

74.5% of families who sought emergency psychiatric care faced CPS involvement or legal consequences — rising to 91.2% among those who described what happened next.

01

Research overview

Three surveys. One documented pattern of institutional harm.

Until They're All Safe conducted a three-survey research initiative examining the experiences of families caring for children with severe attachment-related disorders — including RAD, FASD, complex trauma, and co-occurring behavioral conditions. Across 320 families and three separate instruments, the data tells a single, consistent story: families were placed with children without adequate disclosure or preparation; denied services when crises emerged; and then threatened with legal consequences when they sought emergency help.

Methodology: Descriptive, cross-sectional, multi-instrument survey study with qualitative thematic analysis. Surveys distributed through UTAS networks, social media, and peer communities. Participation voluntary and self-selected. Author: Kristina Miller, Founder & Executive Director, Until They're All Safe · July 2026. Data collection is now closed. This is the final dataset used for peer-reviewed publication and federal policy submissions.

02

Survey 1 · n = 317

The emergency room became a trap.

Survey 1 captured 317 families navigating active behavioral crises. 75% had brought their child to an emergency room seeking psychiatric care. What happened next defines the central finding of this research.

Key Finding

74.5% of families who brought their child to the emergency room for a psychiatric crisis faced CPS involvement or legal consequences as a result (n=178 of 239). Among the families who described specifically what happened next, that rate rises to 91.2%. Roughly 1 in 4 walked away with zero consequences. The ER — designed to provide care — remains a primary entry point for family criminalization.

What the system told families seeking help

"We have nothing else to offer"75%
"This is a parenting issue"61%
"Call the police"59%
"Seeking help could be abandonment"47%
"Try another parenting class"41%

Consequences after ER visit

Any CPS or legal consequence (full sample)74.5%
Consequence, among those who described what happened91.2%
CPS involvement69%
Threatened with abandonment or neglect charges43%
Faced zero consequences of any kind26%

What families did on their own

Installed locks or alarms86%
Installed cameras80%
Sought multiple evaluations78%
Paid out of pocket73%
Quit work or reduced hours55%

Caregiver impact

PTSD symptoms92%
Severe sleep deprivation70%
Relationship breakdown68%
Health issues56%
Job loss25%

This pattern held regardless of insurance type. Medicaid: 77%. Privately insured: 67%. Both: 75%. This is not a poverty problem. It is a structural failure.

RAD and mood disorders are NOT always the result of poor parenting. You cannot love brain wiring into its correct place. An attempt for help should NOT mean automatic CPS reports.

— Survey 1 respondent

03

Survey 2 · n = 190

The behaviors professionals couldn't see.

Survey 2 focused on the specific patterns of relational harm and coercive manipulation occurring inside family households — and on how professionals responded when families described them. Nearly every respondent confirmed they had observed these patterns in their home.

98%

Observed manipulation or coercive patterns in their home

79%

Behaviors occurring daily — not weekly. Daily.

97%

Reported safety concerns in the home

92%

Caregivers with PTSD symptoms — 39% formally diagnosed

Patterns observed inside the home

Gaslighting or denial of events93%
Charming in public, dangerous at home90%
Splitting caregivers against each other87%
Lying to undermine caregiver credibility84%
False or exaggerated allegations79%
Threatening self-harm to control67%
Threatening to report caregivers57%

How professionals responded

Minimization or disbelief72%
Told services were unavailable58%
Blamed on parenting style56%
"Normal parenting stress"48%
Accused of exaggerating44%
Believed and supported36%

85% of respondents said professionals believed the child over the caregiver — without investigation.

The Chilling Effect

80% changed what they shared with professionals out of fear of being disbelieved or reported. The system created the silence — then used it against families.

These behaviors amount to domestic violence. If my spouse treated me the way my child with RAD treats me, there would be supports and safe houses in place. We are expected to continue living with our abuser and "just get over it."

— Survey 2 respondent

04

Survey 3 · n = 141

Families were set up to fail.

Survey 3 documents what happened before families were placed with these children. The crises in Surveys 1 and 2 were not accidental. They were the predictable consequence of a system that withheld critical information, provided no preparation, and abandoned families after placement.

Key Finding

70% received no verbal disclosure before the child entered their home. 48% learned of their child's diagnoses or the true severity of their behaviors only after placement. 85% say the lack of disclosure directly contributed to safety risks in their home.

Pre-placement disclosure

Nothing disclosed verbally70%
No written records provided48%
Full file never received53%
Complete records before placement6%

Pre-placement training

No training on attachment disorders89%
No written protocols for high-risk behaviors92%
No training topics addressed at all67%

Post-adoption services — denied or delayed

At least one service denied or delayed88%
Services not available68%
Insurance or funding barriers60%
Child deemed "too complex"36%
Child deemed "too behavioral"36%

Children were deemed too complex and too behavioral by the same system that placed them without disclosure or preparation.

Retaliation for seeking help post-adoption

Warned help = neglect or abandonment39%
Fear affected whether they sought help63%
Lack of disclosure contributed to safety risks84%

Caseworkers trying to get children adopted are not disclosing the full truth about kids with severe developmental and behavioral disorders. They create a false story of the children to get them adopted. This is deceptive and harmful for the children and families trying to adopt.

— Survey 3 respondent

05

Neurodevelopmental risk factors · n = 317

The behaviors have a dose-response curve.

This finding was not something we set out to prove. It emerged from the data itself. Every child in Survey 1 was scored against 13 documented neurodevelopmental risk factors — prenatal exposure, early neglect, attachment disruption, medical trauma, and diagnosed conditions. The more risk factors a child carries, the more severe and dangerous their behaviors become. This is not a hypothesis. It is a pattern the data produced on its own.

6.33

Mean neurodevelopmental risk factors carried per child, out of 13 measured

98%

Of children carry 2 or more risk factors

48%

Of children carry 7 or more risk factors — the "high load" group

153

Children in the high neurodevelopmental load group

Behavior severity rises with neurodevelopmental load

1–4 risk factors → 5–7 risk factors → 8–13 risk factors

Aggression toward caregivers

94%

Self-harm / suicidality

77%

False allegations

72%

Elopement into danger

68%

Animal harm

64%

Weapons access attempts

39%

Rates shown are for children in the highest load group (8–13 risk factors). Every behavior above rises consistently from the lowest to the highest load group.

High Neurodevelopmental Load Group (7+ factors, n=153)

78% have required an ER visit. 76% show self-harm or suicidal ideation. 60% have made homicidal threats. 58% show animal harm. These are not random behaviors — they are the predictable output of stacked neurodevelopmental injury with no intervention.

This relationship is statistically significant (p < .0001) and holds across the full 317-family dataset — not a small or cherry-picked subgroup. It reframes the entire report: these are not families with "difficult children." These are families managing a documented, measurable, escalating neurodevelopmental crisis that the system was never built to recognize.

06

Cross-survey synthesis

The five-stage arc of institutional harm.

Read individually, each survey documents a serious problem. Read together, they document a system. 320 families across three instruments describe the same arc of harm in consistent detail.

1

Fraudulent Entry

70% received no verbal disclosure. Nearly half learned of diagnoses or true behavior severity after placement. Some families were coerced into sibling groups under threat of losing future placement eligibility. What the system describes as "adoption" was, for most of these families, uninformed consent.

2

Abandonment After Placement

88% were denied at least one post-placement service. 89% received no training on attachment disorders. Post-adoption support evaporated. Families with no training, no protocols, and no support were expected to manage complex psychiatric presentations alone.

3

Crisis Without Response

75% were told "we have nothing to offer." 59% were told to call the police. 85% of professionals believed the child over the caregiver without investigation — because the child had already learned to be more credible in public.

4

Criminalization of Help-Seeking

When families escalated to emergency care, 74.5% faced CPS or legal consequences — 91.2% among those who described exactly what happened. 43% were threatened with abandonment or neglect charges. The system used help-seeking as evidence of failure.

5

Silencing

80% changed what they shared with professionals out of fear. The system created the silence — and then used that silence against families. The loop closed. Families became invisible, isolated, and increasingly unsafe.

"If anything, we are under-reporting because we are downplaying them."

— Survey 1 respondent

07

Family support

You are not the only family living this.

Every number on this page is a household. If the fraudulent entry, the abandonment after placement, the crisis without response, the criminalization, or the silence described above is your life right now — this research exists because of families like yours, and it was always meant to lead somewhere. Safe Harbor is the advocacy support UTAS built for exactly this: families navigating extreme behaviors, system involvement, and placement crisis, at whatever stage you're in.

Safe Harbor Advocacy Initiative

Built directly from this data — support and resources that correspond to each stage of the arc documented here, from disclosure failures through crisis and system involvement.

You do not have to be further into crisis than you are right now to reach out.

Message the institute

08

Family voices

What families say must change.

Open-text responses across all three surveys reveal consistent, specific demands. These are not vague requests for "more support." They are precise, actionable, and urgent.

Believe us. We are not exaggerating — if anything, we are underreporting.

Mandatory full disclosure of all behavioral history, diagnoses, and prior placements before any placement.

RAD training for ER physicians, CPS workers, judges, schools, and law enforcement.

Residential treatment pathways that don't require custody relinquishment or criminal investigation to access.

Legal protection for families who seek emergency psychiatric care for their children.

Recognition that child-to-caregiver and child-to-sibling abuse is real and requires protective response.

Every single time you choose not to favor the parents, you are giving the child with unhealed trauma responses and brain damage more power and control over the family. No one can be hypervigilant 24/7 years on end. Without real help this will end in tragedy.

— Survey 2 respondent

If a medical facility cannot house and care for the child safely for treatment due to behaviors — how can a family, especially with other children to keep safe, be expected to house and care for the child safely inside their home?

— Survey 3 respondent

09

Final dataset

The findings are final.

Data collection for this research closed in July 2026 at 320 families and 648 survey submissions. These findings are now being prepared for peer-reviewed publication and federal policy submission. Explore the full record or read what it means for policy.

Voluntary, confidential, parent-reported data. Reported only in aggregate for research, policy, and advocacy use.

The full dataset review is available after signing in. No purchase is required.

Access the full dataset